Energy and the environment

Energy Efficiency vs Fuel Efficiency: Where the Energy Goes

Detailed shot of a classic car engine bay highlighting intricate design
Photo by Selvin Esteban on Pexels. A general illustration, not evidence for any number.

Energy efficiency is the share of the energy you put into a machine that comes out as the thing you wanted: motion, light or heat. Fuel economy is something else. It counts how far a vehicle travels on a unit of fuel, such as miles per gallon, and says nothing by itself about how much energy that fuel contained.

The two numbers can point in different directions. A car can post a better mpg figure on a denser fuel without using less energy per mile, and an electric car can look very efficient at the wall socket while much of the fuel energy behind that electricity was lost earlier, at the power plant. This article separates the measures, shows where the energy goes in a gasoline vehicle, and gives you a way to read any efficiency claim.

Two measures, two different questions

The U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) defines energy efficiency as a ratio of service provided to energy input. For a light bulb the service is light and the input is watts. For a car the service is movement down the road and the input is the energy stored in the fuel tank.

Fuel economy is a distance-per-fuel ratio. In the United States it is usually written as miles per gallon (mpg). The inverse, gallons per 100 miles, is easier to add up over a trip. A fuel-economy figure has no energy unit in it. To turn it into energy per mile you need the energy content of a gallon of that fuel, which is why energy units like Btu, joules and kilowatt-hours matter here.

Where the energy goes in a gasoline vehicle

The Department of Energy's fueleconomy.gov site says that only about 12% to 30% of the energy in the fuel of a conventional vehicle is used to move it down the road. The rest is lost along the way. The site says most of the fuel's energy is lost in the engine, primarily as heat. That is built into how a gasoline engine burns fuel.

Where the fuel energy goes in a conventional gasoline vehicle, by driving pattern (fueleconomy.gov, "Where the Energy Goes: Gasoline Vehicles").
Where the energy goesCity drivingHighway drivingCombined (55% city, 45% highway)
Engine losses71% to 75%64% to 69%68% to 72%
Accessories (parasitic losses)5% to 7%3% to 4%4% to 6%
Idling6%none3%
Transmission and driveline4% to 5%3% to 5%3% to 5%
Reaches the wheels14% to 20%22% to 30%18% to 25%

Two patterns stand out. First, the engine is the largest loss in every row. Second, the driving pattern changes the picture: city driving adds idling and stop-and-go engine losses, while highway driving has little idling.

Why the same mpg can hide different energy use

A gallon of diesel holds more energy than a gallon of gasoline, so miles per gallon is not a fair comparison between the two without a correction. AFDC, the Department of Energy's Alternative Fuels Data Center, lists gasoline at up to 116,090 Btu per gallon (32.36 MJ/L), the top of its range and the value the Comparator uses for no-ethanol gasoline. It lists low-sulfur diesel at 128,488 Btu per gallon (35.81 MJ/L). Both are on a lower heating value (LHV) basis. If you are unsure what that basis means, see higher versus lower heating value.

Worked example, with two imaginary cars that both achieve 30 mpg (7.8 L/100 km):

  • Gasoline car: 116,090 Btu per gallon ÷ 30 miles per gallon = about 3,870 Btu per mile (4.08 MJ).
  • Diesel car: 128,488 Btu per gallon ÷ 30 miles per gallon = about 4,283 Btu per mile (4.52 MJ).
  • The diesel car uses about 11% more energy per mile (4,283 ÷ 3,870 = 1.107), even though the mpg labels match.
  • For the diesel car to match the gasoline car's energy per mile, it would need 128,488 ÷ 3,870 = about 33 mpg.

The same ratio holds on a higher heating value basis (138,490 ÷ 124,340 = about 1.11). Fueleconomy.gov says diesel fuel has roughly 10% to 15% more energy than gasoline, and that diesel vehicles can often travel about 20% to 35% farther on a gallon. Part of that gap comes from the engine, and part is simply that the gallon holds more energy. You can compare the fuels directly in the Comparator for gasoline, diesel and grid electricity, and the gasoline-gallon equivalent article explains the unit built to make such comparisons.

Electricity: the losses happen before the outlet

For electric vehicles, EPA reports miles per gallon of gasoline equivalent (MPGe). It assumes that a gallon of gasoline has the energy of 33.7 kWh (121.3 MJ), so a vehicle that uses 33.7 kWh to drive 100 miles scores 100 MPGe. EPA says these values include charging losses measured from the wall outlet. They stop at the outlet. They do not include what happened at the power plant.

Fueleconomy.gov says an all-electric vehicle converts over 77% of the electrical energy from the grid to power at the wheels. That figure also starts at the grid. Before that, EIA's analysis of 2019 data found that utility-scale power plants in the United States used about 38 quadrillion Btu of fuel energy to produce about 14 quadrillion Btu of electricity, and that natural gas plants converted 45% of their fuel energy into net generation while coal plants converted 32%. EIA also estimates that transmission and distribution losses averaged about 5% of the electricity transmitted and distributed from 2018 through 2022. How a plant makes electricity from heat is covered in how power plants turn fuel into electricity.

Stages multiply. As an illustration only, take a gas-fired plant at 45%, a grid that delivers 95% of what enters it, and a vehicle that turns 77% of grid electricity into wheel power: 0.45 × 0.95 × 0.77 = 0.329, or about 33% of the plant's fuel energy. That mixes years and averages, and it leaves out extraction and refining steps on every fuel path, so treat it as a demonstration of multiplication, not a verdict on any technology.

A short checklist for reading any efficiency number:

  • What energy goes in: the fuel, the electricity at the wall, or the electricity at the power plant?
  • What counts as the useful output: wheel power, shaft power, delivered heat?
  • Which steps are left out: fuel production, power generation, delivery?
  • Which heating-value basis was used, and was it the same for every fuel compared?

Common mistakes

  • Treating mpg as a percentage. A car rated at 30 mpg is not "30% efficient." Fuel economy and efficiency use different denominators.
  • Comparing mpg across fuels. A gallon of diesel and a gallon of gasoline hold different amounts of energy, so equal mpg means unequal energy per mile.
  • Assuming driving pattern does not matter. The same vehicle loses energy differently in the city and on the highway, as the table shows.
  • Reading 77% as a start-to-finish figure. That number starts with grid electricity. The conversion losses at the power plant come earlier.
  • Mixing LHV and HHV. Dividing one fuel's lower heating value by another fuel's higher heating value produces a wrong ratio.

Frequently asked questions

Is energy efficiency the same as fuel economy?

No. Energy efficiency is the useful energy output divided by the energy input, so it is a ratio with a ceiling of 100%. Fuel economy is distance per unit of fuel, such as miles per gallon. You can convert fuel economy into energy per mile only if you know how much energy a unit of the fuel contains.

Does a higher mpg always mean less energy used?

Not across different fuels. A gallon of low-sulfur diesel holds about 11% more energy than a gallon of no-ethanol gasoline on the LHV basis used here. Two cars at the same mpg on those fuels therefore use different amounts of energy per mile. Within a single fuel, higher mpg does mean less fuel and less energy per mile.

What does MPGe leave out?

EPA's MPGe counts electricity measured at the wall outlet, including charging losses, using 33.7 kWh per gallon of gasoline as the exchange rate. It does not count what was lost generating and delivering that electricity. It answers how far a vehicle goes on energy measured at the wall, not on the fuel burned at the power plant.

Sources

Spotted something wrong or out of date? Tell us through the corrections page. We answer within 10 business days.