Biofuels and alternatives

Gray, Blue and Green Hydrogen: What the Colors Mean

Vibrant abstract liquid bubbles in yellow-orange and green-blue hues
Photo by Marie Gaebel on Pexels. A general illustration, not evidence for any number.

Hydrogen colors are informal labels for how a batch of hydrogen was produced. Gray usually means made from natural gas without capturing the carbon dioxide (CO2), blue means made from fossil fuel with the CO2 captured and stored, and green means made by splitting water with renewable electricity. The gas itself is the same molecule in every case.

The labels are useful shorthand and a poor measure. A congressional research report says the labels are not standardized, and the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) reports that the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) does not use them. What counts for the climate is how much greenhouse gas the production chain emits per kilogram of hydrogen, and that number can differ a lot within a single color. This article lays out what each label usually means and what the numbers behind them look like. What hydrogen holds in energy terms is a separate question, answered in hydrogen as a fuel.

What each color usually means

The Congressional Research Service (CRS), the research arm of Congress, gives the clearest public summary. Some producers, marketers, governments and other organizations use a color spectrum, it says, and some production routes have no color at all.

Common hydrogen color labels and the production route each usually describes, following CRS.
LabelUsual meaningTypical process
GrayHydrogen from natural gas or petroleum, with no carbon captureSteam methane reforming (SMR)
BrownHydrogen from coal, with no carbon captureCoal gasification
BlueHydrogen from fossil fuel, typically SMR, with the CO2 captured and storedSMR plus carbon capture
GreenHydrogen from water using renewable electricityElectrolysis
PinkHydrogen produced with nuclear energyVaries
TurquoiseHydrogen produced from hydrocarbons by pyrolysisHeating the feedstock without oxygen

The table is a map, not a rulebook. A route that does not fit, such as electrolysis powered by fossil-fuel electricity, has no agreed color. Different organizations also draw the boundaries differently, so a color on a product label is only as precise as the definition behind it.

Why gray dominates today

SMR reacts natural gas with high-temperature steam over a catalyst, and the carbon in the methane ends up as CO2. CRS reported in October 2024 that SMR accounted for about 95 percent of U.S. hydrogen and about 76 percent of hydrogen worldwide, with coal gasification adding 4 percent in the United States. Electrolysis supplied about 1 percent of U.S. hydrogen and about 2 percent of global hydrogen. EIA likewise calls SMR the process behind nearly all commercially produced hydrogen in the United States.

Most hydrogen produced in the United States would therefore fall under the gray or brown label. CRS notes that significant electrolyzer capacity has been announced, but electrolysis starts from a small base in the figures above. DOE's Hydrogen Fuel Basics page gives a similar figure: about 95 percent from steam reforming of natural gas.

The numbers behind the labels

The figures below come from a DOE laboratory study and from the International Energy Agency (IEA), the latter as reported by CRS.

Reported greenhouse gas emissions per kilogram of hydrogen. The studies and boundaries differ, so read them as ranges, not a ranking.
Casekg CO2e per kg H2Source
SMR without capture (NETL Case 1A), cradle to plant gate12NETL, 2022
SMR with capture (NETL Case 2), cradle to plant gateabout 4.6Derived from NETL
Electrolysis on the average global gridabout 24IEA, as reported by CRS
Electrolysis with solar photovoltaic power0.9 to 2.5IEA, as reported by CRS
Electrolysis with onshore wind power0.4 to 0.8IEA, as reported by CRS

CO2e means CO2-equivalent, a way of adding up different greenhouse gases in one unit. DOE's National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) modeled a stand-alone SMR plant and found 12 kg CO2e per kg of hydrogen, measured from natural gas production to the plant gate. About three quarters of that, 9.3 kg, came from CO2 in the plant's own stack, and about 22 percent from producing the natural gas.

Adding capture cuts the total by about 62 percent in NETL's model, which is where the 4.6 comes from (12 multiplied by 0.38). It does not reach zero, because the plant still needs natural gas and grid electricity, and capture does not remove the emissions from making those. The capture cases recover more than 90 percent of the carbon entering the plant, and NETL says its results vary by about 25 percent.

The electrolysis rows show the opposite lesson. CRS reports that the source of the electricity largely sets the emissions of electrolytic hydrogen. Hydrogen made with the average global grid comes out near 24 kg CO2e per kg, about as high as unabated coal gasification at 23. So "made from water" is not the same as "green."

A worked conversion

Studies quote kilograms of CO2e per kilogram of hydrogen. To compare with other fuels, which are quoted per unit of energy, divide by hydrogen's energy per kilogram. On a lower heating value basis that is 120 MJ/kg. NETL's 12 kg CO2e/kg becomes 12 divided by 120, or 0.10 kg per MJ, about 100 g CO2e per MJ. That stops at the plant gate, before delivery and use, so it should not be set beside well-to-wheels figures for gasoline. Compare it only with other cradle-to-gate hydrogen results.

Why agencies use a number instead of a color

Because labels say little about the total, U.S. policy documents set thresholds in kilograms of CO2e per kilogram of hydrogen instead. DOE's Clean Hydrogen Production Standard guidance, dated June 2023, sets a target of 4.0 kg CO2e per kg for life-cycle emissions measured well to gate. CRS explains that this is not a regulatory standard. A separate definition in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act calls hydrogen "clean" at 2 kg CO2e per kg or less measured at the site of production. As of November 2026, DOE's Hydrogen Program page still presents the 2023 guidance, and the CRS report cited here is dated October 2024.

The two thresholds use different boundaries, so they are not interchangeable. Converted at 120 MJ/kg, 4.0 kg per kg is about 33 g CO2e per MJ, and 2 kg per kg is about 17 g. Whatever the color, a number with a stated boundary lets two production routes be compared on equal terms.

Combustion is a different question

At the point of use the colors make no difference. EPA states that hydrogen contains no carbon and so releases no CO2 when burned. The Comparator shows 0 g CO2 per MJ for combustion, and records the 12 kg CO2e/kg cradle-to-gate figure above as a separate life-cycle measure, because the two answer different questions. For how such boundaries work, see life cycle assessment of fuels, and for how labels like "clean" and "neutral" get used, carbon-neutral fuel claims. To see the hydrogen row, open hydrogen in the Comparator.

Common mistakes

  • Treating the colors as official categories. CRS says the labels are not standardized, and EIA reports that DOE does not use them. A seller's "blue" may not match another's.
  • Assuming green means zero emissions. Electrolysis on a fossil-heavy grid can emit more than SMR. The electricity source decides.
  • Assuming blue means near zero. In NETL's model capture leaves about 4.6 kg CO2e per kg, because upstream gas production and electricity still count.
  • Merging combustion and life-cycle figures. Hydrogen emits no CO2 when burned, yet the chain that made it can emit a lot. The two are separate measures.
  • Comparing kilograms of CO2e per kilogram of hydrogen with figures per MJ or per kWh without converting. Divide by the energy per kilogram first, and check that the boundaries match.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between gray, blue and green hydrogen?

Gray hydrogen comes from natural gas or petroleum with the CO2 released. Blue uses the same fossil feedstock but captures and stores the CO2. Green is made by electrolysis, splitting water with renewable electricity. These are informal labels, and CRS notes they are not standardized.

Does the U.S. Department of Energy use hydrogen colors?

No. EIA reports that DOE does not use the color code others use to categorize hydrogen, and supports production pathways whatever their source. DOE instead describes hydrogen by carbon intensity, such as its 4.0 kg CO2e per kg target measured from well to gate.

Is blue hydrogen carbon-free?

No. Capture can recover more than 90 percent of the CO2 released at the plant, but the natural gas still has to be produced, and in NETL's model those upstream and electricity emissions leave about 4.6 kg CO2e per kg. Results depend on the capture rate, methane leakage and electricity source.

Which color is most common today?

Gray, in the sense of hydrogen from natural gas without capture. CRS reported in October 2024 that SMR made about 95 percent of U.S. hydrogen and about 76 percent of the world's, while electrolysis made about 1 percent in the United States.

Sources

Spotted something wrong or out of date? Tell us through the corrections page. We answer within 10 business days.